chat

Fighting for the Rights
of Today's Families

In Re: Baby S

Click below to share this on social media:

Former The View host, Sherri Shepherd may no longer appear on the talk show, yet she remains in the public eye due to her recent appeal to the Pennsylvania Superior Court. Ms. Shepherd’s case concerns a baby born to Ms. Shepherd and her former husband via surrogacy.

In 2011, Sherri Shepherd married Lamar Sally, and shortly thereafter the two contacted Reproductive Possibilities to assist them in arranging a contract with a surrogate mother. In the contract that Ms. Shepherd and Mr. Sally signed with Reproductive Possibilities, the prospective parents stated their desire to have a child via a surrogate, as all client’s of the company do. The agreement provided that Ms. Shepherd and Mr. Sally could terminate the arrangement at any time prior to the time that the gestational carrier becomes pregnant. The surrogate that was matched with Shepherd and Sally resided in Pennsylvania. Shepherd and Sally additionally entered into an agreement with Tiny Treasures who provided the egg donation. in the contact with this company, the prospective parents gain reiterated their desire to have a child via a surrogacy arrangement. This recitation of Shepherd and Sally’s consent indemnified the egg donor from any legal responsibility.

Several months later, once the surrogate mother was pregnant, Shepherd refused to sign documents that were required to allow her name to be on the child’s birth certificate. Shepherd’s refusal was due to the dissolution of her marriage with Sally. Due to the failure to file the necessary documents with the court, neither Sally or Shepherd’s name were on the child’s birth certificate when the child was born.

Upon trial, the court found that the surrogacy agreement was a valid and enforceable contact, and the Shepherd had breached it. She was found to not only have financial obligations to care for the child, but she also was responsible for the birth mother’s legal fees. Shepherd appealed and argued that the agreement was unenforceable under Pennsylvania law. Shepherd argued that the agreement was “an unlawful means of circumventing the statutory adoption procedure.” The appellate court disagreed. The court held that only “in the clearest of cases may a court declare a contract void as against public policy” The baby would not have been born but for Sally and Shepherd’s agreement, and their clearly stated intention to become parents binds them both to the contract they entered into.

As Shepherd does not have a relationship with the now year-old child, this case is primarily about the child support she now owes to Sally, who is parenting the child on his own. As in any case, the amount of child support owed by the non-custodial parent may be properly determined by a court.

As the Court noted in this case, there is a growing acceptance of alternative reproductive arrangements” in Pennsylvania and in the United States. This Decision certainly sets precedent that the Court intends to support and uphold the various paths to parenthood.

Request A Consultation by filling out the form below.

  • Contact Lisa Marie Vari & Associates, P.C.
  • Let us make this process easier. Contact us by email below or call 1-844-VARI-LAW (1-844-827-4529) to schedule a confidential consultation.
[]
1 Step 1
Previous
Next
powered by FormCraft

Pennsylvania Office Locations

Allegheny County – Main Office

Manor Building, Penthouse Suite
564 Forbes Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: 412-281-9906
Get Directions

Washington County:

2400 Ansys Dr., Suite 102
Canonsburg, PA 15317
Phone: 724-436-5500
Get Directions

Butler County Law Office

2009 Mackenzie Way, Suite 184
Cranberry Township, PA 16066
Phone: 724-776-9906
Get Directions

Clearfield County Law Office

Lisa Marie Vari & Associates, P.C.
114 1/2 S. Second Street
Clearfield, PA 16830
Phone: 814-290-0587
Get Directions

Allegheny County – Main Office

Manor Building, Penthouse Suite 564 Forbes Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: 412-281-9906
Get Directions

Washington County Office

2400 Ansys Dr., Suite 102 Canonsburg, PA 15317
Phone: 724-436-5500
Get Directions

Butler County Law Office

2009 Mackenzie Way, Suite 184 Cranberry Township, PA 16066
Phone: 724-776-9906
Get Directions

Clearfield County Law Office

Lisa Marie Vari & Associates, P.C. 114 1/2 S. Second StreetClearfield, PA 16830
Phone: 814-290-0587
Get Directions

Miami-Dade County

1200 Brickell Avenue, Suite 1950
Miami, FL 33131
Phone: 305-222-7351
Get Directions

Swipe for More Locations

Florida Meeting Location

Connect With Us
Miami-Dade County

1200 Brickell Avenue, Suite 1950
Miami, FL 33131
Phone: 305-222-7351
Get Directions

Request a Consultation

request a consultation

by filling out the form below
  • Schedule A Confidential Consultation.
[]
1 Step 1
Previous
Next
powered by FormCraft